Risk Management · 2024
In this section3 topics
Risk Management Policy & Plan
Policy & Plan Description
The Company recognizes the importance of risk management under changing internal and external factors that may affect the business. Risk management is an integral part of good corporate governance and a key foundation that enables the Company to achieve its defined business objectives sustainably, build confidence among investors and stakeholders, and enable executives to make better decisions. This can help reduce volatility in operating results, increase the efficiency of using critical resources, and prepare for new risks that may arise in the future.
The Company has established an internal control, audit, and reporting system through monthly meetings to monitor operational results, cost control, and jointly adjust strategies to ensure the Company's strength and maintain its competitive potential. In addition, the Board of Directors has established a Risk and Investment Management Committee to formulate risk management policies covering the entire organization. It also oversees the establishment of risk management systems or processes to control risks and mitigate their impact on the Company's business. Its key responsibilities include identifying risks related to the Company's business operations, establishing preventive measures, and monitoring the appropriate implementation of such measures. The committee is also assigned to have the Audit Committee review and assess the adequacy and appropriateness of the internal control system for the business operation.
Risks to the Company's Business Operations
Risk Register
| Risk Name | Risk Characteristics | Consequences | Management Measures | Related Risk Factors |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Risks of Competition in the Private Hospital Business | Currently, the private hospital business is quite competitive, with both existing and new operators opening new hospitals across Thailand following the expansion of communities and the increasing demand for medical care. | The decrease in the number of patients has resulted in a decline in revenue. | However, hospital businesses will need to compete on their ability to treat difficult and complex diseases, with both quality and price being important factors. The Company focuses on developing the quality of its services and providing modern and safe medical equipment at a fair price to service recipients. In addition, Ramkhamhaeng Hospital continues to develop its level of treatment for difficult and complex diseases through the establishment of various centers of excellence, such as the Heart Center, Brain and Nervous System Center, and Radiation Therapy Center, to provide treatment to patients within the hospital and referrals from hospitals within the network. Furthermore, the Company's hospitals provide treatment to all types of patients, including self-paying patients, patients under the Social Security program, and patients under the Universal Health Coverage scheme, allowing patients to choose the appropriate treatment options according to their healthcare rights, which is a strength of the Ramkhamhaeng Hospital Group. | 1714 · Description: Competition risk · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK |
| Risks from processes and operating procedures | The operation of private hospitals, potential risks that may arise in the service process, or other risks that will affect the provision of nursing care to patients. | Being sued, resulting in damage to image and reputation. | The management considers risk management a crucial policy within the organization, prioritizing patient safety. This emphasis on patient care processes ensures maximum safety for all patients. The hospital has established a Risk Management and Investment Committee responsible for overseeing and monitoring various risks. This committee works to develop solutions, implement corrective actions, and establish preventive measures. Their scope encompasses the entire organization and addresses various risk categories, including physical risks, process-related risks, occupational safety and health, patient rights, and organizational ethics. Simultaneously, the management prioritizes staff development to ensure a comprehensive understanding and adherence to the standards outlined in the hospital's policies. | 741 · Description: Systems or internal control system · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 742 · Description: Human error in business operations · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 749 · Description: Safety, occupational health, and working environment · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK |
| Risks from Changes in Social Security Policies | In 1984, the Group's revenue from social security services accounted for approximately 15-20 percent of total medical treatment revenue, making it vulnerable to changes in social security policies. | - | However, the Company Group believes that the social security system has a secure fund and a stable disbursement system. Although there have been changes in the reimbursement policy for medical expenses, it is in line with the increasing adjustments in actual medical costs. Furthermore, the Company Group's management has closely monitored the policies of the social security program. There is also continuous monitoring of the procedures and criteria for medical expense reimbursements with the Social Security Office to ensure accurate and complete reimbursements following the Office's conditions. This also helps control related medical expenses to mitigate risks that may impact the Company Group's future operating results. | 756 · Description: Change in laws and regulations · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK · 757 · Description: Laws and regulations is not favorable for doing business · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK |
| Regulatory risk | The Company operates its business under the supervision and regulation of the Ministry of Public Health and other relevant government agencies. It is also required to obtain licenses to operate a healthcare facility and a hospital, and must comply with laws relating to hospitals, companies, and other relevant laws. Any changes in the interpretation of current regulations or the enactment of new laws or regulations, or the introduction of new policies that are likely to be more stringent, may have an impact on the Company's operations. | May violate relevant rules, regulations, and laws, and be subject to lawsuits. | However, the Company has implemented and complied with various important quality system standards, such as the international ACCI (American Accreditation Commission International) standard, the HA (Hospital Accreditation) standard of the Ministry of Public Health, and ISO9001:2015, which require the Company to operate and comply with standards to control the quality of patient care and oversee safety, the environment, and risks in various areas. This may help mitigate the impacts that may arise from changes in relevant regulations or laws. | 756 · Description: Change in laws and regulations · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK · 757 · Description: Laws and regulations is not favorable for doing business · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK · 758 · Description: Violations of laws and regulations · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK |
| Litigation risk | Medical service businesses are at risk of lawsuits from patients or related individuals who may be dissatisfied with medical treatment. | The hospital may have to pay compensation for damages or suffer damage to the hospital's reputation in the future. | The Company is aware of these risk factors and has developed, monitored, and controlled the operations of each hospital to ensure quality and safety for service recipients. There is also a Risk and Investment Management Committee, which is responsible for working and monitoring various risk issues of the hospital in order to take suggestions and complaints from patients or related persons for continuous development and improvement. As of December 31, 2024, some patients who received treatment at the hospital and were not satisfied with the treatment results, possibly due to miscommunication and misunderstanding, have filed lawsuits, and 4 cases are still in court proceedings: 1) Case No. 1: The claim amount is 2.70 million baht. The Court of First Instance ruled to dismiss the plaintiff's case on April 18, 2015. On December 19, 2023, the Court of Appeal upheld the Court of First Instance's ruling to dismiss the plaintiff's case. Subsequently, the plaintiff filed an appeal. The case is currently under consideration by the Supreme Court. 2) Case No. 2: The claim amount is 2.21 million baht. The plaintiff filed the lawsuit on December 14, 2021. The court ruled to dismiss the plaintiff's case on January 24, 2022. Subsequently, the plaintiff filed an appeal on April 18, 2023. The case is currently under consideration by the Court of Appeal. 3) Case No. 3: The claim amount is 5.03 million baht. The plaintiff filed the lawsuit on April 12, 2023. The defendant filed a statement of defense on June 12, 2023. The Civil Court ruled to dismiss the plaintiff's case on September 24, 2024. The case is currently pending the defendant's filing of an appeal. 4) Case No. 4: The claim amount is 2.00 million baht. The plaintiff filed the lawsuit on May 23, 2013. The defendant filed a statement of defense on July 24, 2013. The court scheduled the defendant's witness hearing on February 6, 2014, and the plaintiff's witness hearing on February 7, 2014. On June 11, 2014, the Civil Court ruled that the two defendants jointly pay the amount of 0.40 million baht with interest at the rate of 5% per year from the date of filing the lawsuit until the payment is completed. The Company filed an appeal on September 12, 2014. The case is currently under consideration by the Court of Appeal. The Company expects that the total amount of damage is not significant compared to the Company's revenue and total assets. | 1723 · Description: Legal risk · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK |
| Healthcare Payment Risk | Private hospitals provide medical treatment before receiving payment, which may pose a risk of non-payment or incomplete payment for medical expenses. | May pose a risk of not receiving full payment for medical treatment. | Therefore, the company has a risk management policy in place, including having the Medical Records Department thoroughly inquire and verify the eligibility of service users, notifying those responsible for expenses of estimated medical expenses in advance, notifying the treatment plan and incurred expenses along with an interim cost estimate, and offering those responsible for treatment costs to pay in installments to reduce risk and alleviate the burden of paying the entire treatment cost upon completion. For collecting treatment fees from contracted companies, there will be a selection and assessment of the credit and financial status of the contracted companies beforehand, as well as periodic reviews of the financial status of the contracted parties and a debt collection department to oversee and reduce the risk of non-payment of treatment fees, attempting to adhere to the specified payment terms. For the treatment of patients under the health insurance scheme of the Social Security Office and the National Health Security Office, the company will collect payments directly from the agencies. In this regard, Ramkhamhaeng Hospital has a portion of medical treatment revenue that is approximately 70% cash and 30% credit terms. Therefore, the risk of non-payment for medical treatment is not significant. | 763 · Description: Default on payment or exchange of goods · Info category: FINANCIAL_RISK |
| Interest rate risk | As of December 31, 2023, the Company had short-term and long-term loans with financial institutions at floating interest rates. Approximately 90 percent of the loans with floating interest rates are based on the 3-month or 6-month fixed deposit interest rate, which has relatively low volatility. The remaining portion is based on the MLR interest rate. | - | However, the Company has complied with the loan agreement conditions and maintained sufficient cash flow for loan repayment. The Company also has a policy of procuring loans with low financing costs. As of December 31, 2023, the Company had a debt-to-equity ratio of 0.50 times (consolidated financial statements). | 764 · Description: Fluctuation in exchange rates, interest rates, or the inflation rate · Info category: FINANCIAL_RISK |
| Environmental Impact Risk | The hospital operates 24 hours a day, relying heavily on electricity to support medical equipment and various support systems. | - | Therefore, the focus is on efficient energy management to reduce environmental impact and enhance sustainability. Under the environmental operational plan, the hospital has implemented comprehensive measures in 4 main areas: climate change management through greenhouse gas emission reduction, energy conservation using efficient technologies, water management and conservation through treatment systems and efficient water use, and safe waste management to reduce environmental impact and promote long-term sustainability. | 751 · Description: Impact on the environment · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 1717 · Description: ESG risk · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK |
| Risk of medical personnel shortage | In the hospital business, physicians are crucial personnel who have a significant impact on business operations. The company has recruited qualified physicians to work at the hospital and regularly sends physicians to attend academic conferences and seminars both domestically and internationally. This allows physicians to apply new knowledge and innovations to patients. In addition to physicians, other personnel, including nurses, pharmacists, physical therapists, radiologists, medical technicians, accounting staff, administrative staff, etc., are also important to the company. Therefore, the company manages and develops its personnel by focusing on 1. Developing the potential of physicians and employees (High Competent Staff) 2. Encouraging physicians and employees to achieve good work performance (High Perform Staff) 3. Developing greater knowledge (Knowledge Management) 4. Promote employee engagement and loyalty to the organization (High Engagement) | Shortage of medical personnel | The company's nationwide network of hospitals, investment in modern medical equipment, continuous expansion and improvement of hospital facilities, comprehensive specialized medical centers, and knowledge exchange among medical teams contribute to physicians' ability to provide comprehensive and integrated multidisciplinary treatment. This effectively mitigates the risk of medical personnel shortages. | 738 · Description: Reliance on employees in key positions · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 739 · Description: Shortage or reliance on skilled workers · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 1717 · Description: ESG risk · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK |
| Personal data breach risk | As the Personal Data Protection Act (PDPA) enacted in 2022 is a broad and non-specific law, it mainly sets forth measures requiring individuals who collect, use, or disclose personal data to have stringent and standardized data protection measures in place. This is considered a preventative measure against potential damage to personal data. Furthermore, the penalty section of the PDPA empowers the court to calculate punitive damages to penalize those who collect or process personal data without consent or violate this Act, whether intentionally or negligently, by requiring them to pay compensation to the data subject. | Violation of relevant rules, regulations, and laws. Litigation. | The company recognizes the importance of complying with the Act. We have planned and implemented measures to ensure compliance with the law to ensure that the company can comply with the law correctly and thoroughly. | 758 · Description: Violations of laws and regulations · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK · 1723 · Description: Legal risk · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK · 1717 · Description: ESG risk · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK |
Risks to Securities Holders' Investment
Risk Register
| Risk Name | Risk Characteristics | Consequences | Management Measures | Related Risk Factors |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Risks from Controlling Shareholder | The company may be controlled by major shareholders. | Major shareholders may exercise the right to object to or disapprove of resolutions at the meeting on matters where the relevant articles of association or laws require a vote of not less than 3 out of 4 of the total number of votes entitled to be cast. | However, as of December 31, 2024, the Company has 2 major shareholders holding shares of 20 percent or more, as follows: 1. F and S 79 Company Limited holds 24.13% of shares. 2. Cypress Consolidated Health Care Pte. Ltd. holds 20.00% of shares. Therefore, the Company does not have any major shareholders with the power to control and influence the Company's decision-making. | 2970 · Description: Risk of the company having a majority shareholder holding > 25% of shares · Info category: HOLDER_RISK |

